In the ever-growing debate surrounding Christian music, it’s easy to see how misplaced priorities have clouded the true purpose of this genre. The loud and misguided voices arguing that only certain rhythms, instruments, or lyrics can be deemed Christian music miss the mark entirely. They fail to recognize that Christian music is not about following a rigid set of rules or pandering to an image of piety, but about speaking biblical truth, no matter the artist or their past.
One of the greatest misconceptions is that Christian music is only valid when it’s produced by artists who explicitly identify as Christian. This narrow-minded view completely disregards the message, which should be the central focus. The music industry is riddled with talented artists whose songs carry more scriptural weight than some so-called “Christian” bands who create music based on cultural or commercial convenience. Do we really think the holiness of a song is defined by the artist’s label or their religious background? If we truly believe that, then we risk allowing pious hypocrisy to shape our definition of what music “belongs” to God.
Let’s not be blind to the truth: a song can carry more biblical depth than a church choir performance, even if it’s created by an artist who isn’t explicitly religious. Mumford & Sons, for instance, have repeatedly produced songs filled with spiritual truths, yet their members aren’t all outspoken Christians. Does that mean their music is any less valuable or impactful? If the lyrics reflect biblical truth—no matter the creator—then the music deserves recognition as a powerful instrument for the kingdom. The message of a song can transcend the artist’s personal faith journey. We shouldn’t dismiss the song simply because of the creator’s personal doubts or lack of confession; after all, God used pagan kings and non-believers to fulfill His will.
Moreover, the obsession with labeling songs based on their sound and instrumentation shows a deep misunderstanding of what true worship is. To claim that certain drum beats, rhythms, or instruments are unholy is not only misguided, it’s also absurd. For centuries, instruments have been used in worship, from the ancient tambourines of Israel to the many instruments mentioned in Psalm 150. The Bible doesn’t prohibit any particular instrument or rhythm; instead, it encourages us to worship in spirit and truth. But somewhere along the way, well-meaning Christians have replaced spiritual depth with superficial forms of worship. They prioritize the appearance of holiness over substance. This isn’t just a problem with instruments or beats; it’s a reflection of a deeper issue where outward appearance is worshipped more than the heart of the worshiper. It’s time we stop elevating preferences and focus on whether the heart behind the music is glorifying God.
And what about those bands that cross over from secular music to mainstream Christian audiences? The fact that Skillet, Lifehouse, or U2 can perform both on Christian and secular platforms should be a wake-up call to the church. Why are we so quick to dismiss their impact on faith because they don’t conform to a manufactured Christian identity? These artists have been open about their faith, and their lyrics—whether written for a secular audience or a Christian one—still carry the truth of the gospel. Are we really going to deny their music simply because it doesn’t fit into our neatly defined box? That’s not discerning; that’s exclusionary and divisive. It’s the message, not the label, that makes a song Christian. And, frankly, to argue otherwise is simply a convenient way for the church to avoid confronting its own prideful, judgmental attitudes.
At the end of the day, the true question we must ask is this: does the music lead us to worship, edify, and draw us closer to God? If the answer is yes, then the song fulfills its role, regardless of the artist’s past, the instruments used, or the genre it falls under. We should stop worshiping at the altar of musical preference and start valuing the truth found in the lyrics. The Bible doesn’t call us to critique the world’s music; it calls us to engage with it and discern what is good, lovely, and true.
Let’s be real: this whole debate over what qualifies as Christian music has become an exercise in hypocrisy. It’s not about the “right” sound or the “correct” artist; it’s about whether the lyrics point to Christ. It’s time we re-evaluate our misplaced priorities and remember that music—no matter the form—is a tool God has given us to glorify His name.
Discussion about this post